Skip to main content

Andrew Sullivan Renounces Conservatism

  • Author:
  • Updated:

By Ben Cohen

I continue to be in awe of Andrew Sullivan's blog - the commitment he has to sharing his every thought with his readers in a consistent and eloquent manner is an incredible feat. Sullivan posts from dawn till dusk every day, and I never tire of reading him. In a painfully honest moment of reflection, Sullivan discusses the political/philosophical revolution he has undergone after watching the movements he came of age in falling apart:

The conservative movement is another institution of a sort that has
come undone before my eyes. It really was a formative part of my
identity as a young man, and yet, for all the reasons I spelled out in
my last book, it is not a movement that I feel comfortable in any
longer. It actually appalls me daily.

What I could once dismiss as minor flaws - supply-side nuttiness,
near-idolatrous American exceptionalism, religious zeal - are now its
core, defining features. The way it has responded to the economic
crisis - a form of ideological autism - reflects a deep malaise. But,
although Obama's pragmatic progressivism has many attractive qualities,
I cannot be a liberal. I do not have liberalism's confidence in
government activism, I do not share its collectivist instincts, I find its
interest groups unappealing. I do not and never will belong.

Maybe this is adulthood finally arriving a little late: the
knowledge that everything is flawed and you just need to get on with
it. But a church perpetrating the rape and abuse of children through
the power of its moral authority is not a flaw; it's a self-refutation.
A movement betraying its core principles in office and then parading as
a parody of purists is a form of anti-conservatism as I understand it. And a democratic country using torture
to procure intelligence it can use to justify more torture, and
prosecuting a war that never ends against an enemy that can never
surrender: this, whatever else it is, is not America as its founders
saw it. Again, it is a kind of self-refutation