We Don’t Need Media Shield Laws

clark-kent-daily-planet-70s

The debate over just how to put together a media shield law illustrates why we don’t need them, and in fact the danger within. It isn’t the job of Congress to determine who, exactly is a journalist.

Already the definitions being offered in the Senate should send up huge warning sounds. Paid, unpaid, size of publication, etc., these are all the sorts of things that should never be enshrined in law.

But the real issue here is that this isn’t 1970, when the distinction between Joe Journalist and Joe Normalcitizen was clear. It sounds like techno-utopian thought, but we really are all journalists. Anyone with any sort of internet access, from email to a Twitter or Facebook account to a blog/website, has the capacity to publish material to a large audience.

In that case, giving a journalist a special right/privilege like the ability to avoid prosecution or being forced to give up a source is either discriminatory because it gives some citizens rights not available to all of us, or useless because the distinction between who is a journalist is nonexistent.

I understand the thinking behind pushing these laws, but before they are even written they’re outmoded and archaic in the 21st century.

 

With an Epic Twitter Tirade, Patton Oswalt Ends the Debate Over Trevor Noah

With an Epic Twitter Tirade, Patton Oswalt Ends the Debate Over Trevor Noah

If you follow Patton Oswalt's career at all, you were waiting for this. Late last night, the comic wRead more...
Fascist <em>WaPo</em> Columnist Says U.S. Has Too Much Democracy, Lauds Iron-Fisted Lee Kuan Yew

Fascist WaPo Columnist Says U.S. Has Too Much Democracy, Lauds Iron-Fisted Lee Kuan Yew

In 2009, everyone's favorite mustachioed goofball Thomas Friedman wrote a truly regrettable column sRead more...
MEMBERS ONLY: The New Arkansas Religious Freedom Law is Actually Worse than the Indiana Law

MEMBERS ONLY: The New Arkansas Religious Freedom Law is Actually Worse than the Indiana Law

Pro-discrimination anti-gay Republicans, including Gov. Mike Pence (R-IN), continue to assert that tRead more...